|
|
|
|
creating an infinite model
|
(Example)
|
|
|
From the syntactic compactness theorem for first order logic, we get this nice (and useful) result:
Let $\T$ be a theory of first-order logic. If $\T$ has finite models of unboundedly large sizes, then $\T$ also has an infinite model.
Proof. Define the propositions $$ \Phi_n \equiv \underline{\exists x_1 \cdots \exists x_n . (x_1\ne x_2)\wedge \cdots \wedge(x_1\ne x_n) \wedge(x_2\ne x_3)\wedge \cdots \wedge(x_{n-1}\ne x_n)} $$ ( $\Phi_n$ says `` there exist (at least) $n$ different elements in the world''). Note that $$\cdots \vdash \Phi_n \vdash \cdots \vdash \Phi_2 \vdash \Phi_1.$$ Define a new theory $$ \T_\infty = \T \cup \left\{\Phi_1, \Phi_2, \ldots \right\}. $$ For any finite subset $\T'\subset \T_\infty$ , we claim that $\T'$ is consistent: Indeed, $\T'$ contains axioms of $\T$ , along with finitely many of $\left\{\Phi_n\right\}_{n\ge 1}$ . Let $\Phi_m$ correspond to the largest index appearing in $\T'$ . If $\M_m\models\T$ is a model of $\T$ with at least $m$ elements (and by hypothesis, such as model exists), then $\M_m\models
\T\cup\{\Phi_m\}\vdash\T'$ .
So every finite subset of $\T_\infty$ is consistent; by the compactness theorem for first-order logic, $\T_\infty$ is consistent, and by Gödel's completeness theorem for first-order logic it has a model $\M$ . Then $\M\models\T_\infty\vdash\T$ , so $\M$ is a model of $\T$ with infinitely many elements ($\M\models \Phi_n$ for any $n$ , so $\M$ has at least $\ge n$ elements for all $n$ ). 
|
"creating an infinite model" is owned by CWoo. [ full author list (3) | owner history (2) ]
|
|
(view preamble | get metadata)
Cross-references: Gödel's completeness theorem, theorem, compactness, hypothesis, index, axioms, contains, consistent, subset, propositions, infinite, sizes, finite, logic, theory, syntactic compactness theorem for first order logic
This is version 6 of creating an infinite model, born on 2002-06-05, modified 2007-12-15.
Object id is 3043, canonical name is UpwardsSkolemLowenheimTheorem.
Accessed 2410 times total.
Classification:
| AMS MSC: | 03B10 (Mathematical logic and foundations :: General logic :: Classical first-order logic) | | | 03C07 (Mathematical logic and foundations :: Model theory :: Basic properties of first-order languages and structures) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pending Errata and Addenda
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|