|
|
|
|
generalized quaternion group
|
(Derivation)
|
|
|
The groups given by the presentation $$ Q_{4n}=\langle a,b : a^n=b^2, a^{2n}=1, b^{-1}ab=a^{-1}\rangl $$ are the generalized quaternion groups. Generally one insists that $n>1$ as the properties of generalized quaternions become more uniform at this stage. However if $n=1$ then one observes $a=b^2$ so $Q_{4n}\cong\mathbb{Z}_4$ . Dihedral group properties are strongly related to generalized quaternion group properties
because of their highly related presentations. We will see this in many of our results.
Proposition 1
- $|Q_{4n}|=4n$ .
- $Q_{4n}$ is abelian if and only if $n=1$ .
- Every element $x\in Q_{4n}$ can be written uniquely as $x=a^i b^j$ where $0\leq i<2n$ and $j=0,1$ .
- $Z(Q_{4n})=\langle a^n\rangle\cong \mathbb{Z}_2$ .
- $Q_{4n}/Z(Q_{4n})\cong D_{2n}$ .
Proof. Given the relation $b^{-1} ab=a^{-1}$ (rather treating it as $ab=ba^{-1}$ ) then as with dihedral groups we can shuffle words in $\{a,b\}$ to group all the $a's$ at the beginning and the $b's$ at the end. So every word takes the form $a^i b^j$ . As $|a|=2n$ and $|b|=4$ we have $0\leq i<2n$ and $0\leq j<4$ . However
we have an added relation that $a^n=b^2$ so we can write $a^i b^2=a^{i+2}$ and also $a^i b^3=a^{i+2}b$ so we restrict to $j=0,1$ . This gives us $4n$ elements of this form which makes the order of $Q_{4n}$ at most $4n$ .
As $a^n=b^2$ it follows $[a^n,a^i b^j]=[a^n,b^j]=[b^2,b^j]=1$ . So $a^n$ is central. If we quotient by $\langle a^n\rangle$ then we have the presentation $$ \langle a,b:a^n=1, b^2=1, b^{-1} ab=a^{-1}\rangl $$ which we recognize as the presentation of the dihedral group. Thus $Q_{4n}/\langle a^n\rangle\cong D_{2n}$ . This prove the order of $Q_{4n}$ is exactly $4n$ . Moreover, given $a^i b^j\in Z(Q_{4n})$ we have $$ 1=[a^i b^j, b]=b^{-j}a^{-i} b^{-1} a^{i} b^j b = b^{-j} a^{-i} a^{-i} b^{-1} b^j b = b^{-j} a^{-2i} b^j = a^{2i} $$ So we have $i=n$ . So $a^n b^j=b^{j+2}$ . Then
$1=[b^{j+2},a]$ forces $j=0,2$ . This means $Z(Q_{4n})=\langle a^n\rangle=\langle b^2\rangle$ . 
As mentioned, if $n=1$ then $Q_4\cong \mathbb{Z}_4$ . If $n=2$ then we have the usual quaternion group $Q_8$ . Because of the genesis of quaternions, this group is often denoted with $i,j,k$ relations as follows: $$ Q_8=\langle -1, i,j,k : i^2=j^2=k^2=-1, ij=k=-1 ji\rangle $$ These relations are responsible for many useful results such as defining cross products for three-dimensional manipulations, and are also responsible for the most common example of a division ring. As a group, $Q_8$ is a curious specimen of a $p$ -group in that it has only normal subgroups yet is non-abelian, it has a unique minimal subgroup and cannot be represented faithfully except by a regular representation - thus requiring degree 8. [To see this note that the unique minmal subgroup is necessarily normal, thus if a proper subgroup is the stabilizer of an action, then the minimal normal subgroup is in the kernel so the representation is not faithful.]
A common work around is to use $2\times 2$ matrices over $\mathbb{C}$ but to treat these as matrices over $\mathbb{R}$ . $$ -1= \begin{bmatrix} -1 & 0 \\ 0 & -1 \end{bmatrix}, \quad i= \begin{bmatrix} i & 0 \\ 0 & -i \end{bmatrix}, \quad j= \begin{bmatrix} 0 & i \\ i & 0 \end{bmatrix}, k= \begin{bmatrix} 0 & -1 \\ 1 & 0 \end{bmatrix}. $$
A worthwhile additional example is $n=3$ . For this produces a group order 12 which is often overlooked.
Proof. As $Q_{4n}/Z(Q_{4n})\cong D_{2n}$ , then if $Q_{4n}$ is Hamiltonian then we require $D_{2n}$ to be as well. However when $n>2$ we know $D_{2n}$ has non-normal subgroups, for example $\langle ab\rangle$ . So we require $n\leq 2$ . If $n=1$ then $Q_{4n}$ is cyclic and so trivially Hamiltonian. When $n=2$ we have the usual quaternion group of order 8 which is Hamiltonian by direct inspection: the conjugacy classes are $\{1\}$ , $\{a^2\}$ , $\{a,a^3\}$ , $\{b,a^2b\}$ and $\{ab,a^3 b\}$ , more commonly described by $\{1\}$ , $\{-1\}$ , $\{i,-i\}$ , $\{j,-j\}$ and $\{k,-k\}$ . In any case, all subgroups are normal. 
By way of converse it can be shown that the only finite Hamiltonian groups are $A\oplus Q_8$ where $A$ is abelian without an element of order 4. One sees already in $\mathbb{Z}_4\oplus Q_8$ that the subgroup $\langle (1,i)\rangle$ is conjugate to the distinct subgroup $\langle (1,-i)\rangle$ and so such groups are not Hamiltonian.
Proposition 3
- $|a^i|=2n/i$ for $1<i\leq 2n$ and $|a^i b|=4$ for all $i$ .
- Every subgroup of $Q_{4n}$ is either cyclic or a generalized quaternion.
- The normal subgroups of $Q_{4n}$ are either subgroups of $\langle a\rangle$ or $n=2^i$ and it is maximal subgroups (of index 2) of which there are 2 acyclic ones.
Proof. The order of elements of $\langle a\rangle$ follows from standard cyclic group theory. Now for $a^i b$ we simply compute: $(a^i b)^2=a^i b a^i b=a^i a^{-i} b^2=b^2$ . So $|a^i b|=4$ .
Now let $H$ be a subgroup of $Q_{4n}$ . If $Z(Q_{4n})\leq H$ then $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ is a subgroup of $D_{2n}$ . We know the subgroups of $D_{2n}$ are either cyclic or dihedral. If $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ is cyclic then $H$ is cyclic (indeed it is a subgroup of $\langle a\rangle$ or $H=\langle a^i b\rangle$ ). So assume that $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ is dihedral. Then we have a dihedral presentation $\langle x,y:x^m=1, y^2=1, y^{-1}xy=x^{-1}\rangle$ for $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ . Now pullback this presentation to $H$ and we find $H$ is quaternion.
Finally, if $H$ does not contain $Z(Q_{4n})$ then $H$ does not contain an element of the form $a^i b$ , so $H\leq \langle a\rangle$ and so it is cyclic.
For the normal subgroup structure, from the relation $b^{-1} ab=a^{-1}$ we see $\langle a\rangle$ is normal. Thus all subgroups of $\langle a\rangle$ are normal as $\langle a\rangle$ is a normal cyclic subgroup. Next suppose $H$ is a normal subgroup not contained in $\langle a\rangle$ . Then $H$ contains some $a^i b$ , and so $H$ contains $Z(Q_{4n})$ . Thus $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ is a normal subgroup of
$D_{2n}$ . We know this forces $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ to be contained in $\langle a\rangle/Z(Q_{4n})$ , a contradiction on our assumptions on $H$ , or $n=2^i$ and $H/Z(Q_{4n})$ is a maximal subgroup (of index 2). 
Proposition 4 $Q_{4n}$ has a unique minimal subgroup if and only if $n=2^i$ .
Proof. If $p|n$ and $p>2$ then $a^{2n/p}$ has order $p$ and so the subgroup $\langle a^{2n/p}\rangle$ is of order $p$ , so it is minimal. As the center is also a minimal subgroup of order 2, then we do not have a unique minimal subgroup in these conditions. Thus $n=2^i$ .
Now suppose $n=2^i$ then $Q_{4n}$ is a $2$ -group so the minimal subgroups must all be of order 2. So we locate the elements of order 2. We have shown $|a^i b|=4$ for any $i$ , and furthermore that $(a^i b)^2=b^2=a^n$ . The only other minimal subgroups will be generated by $a^i$ for some $i$ , and as $|a|=2^{i+1}$ there is a unique minimal subgroup. 
It can also be shown that any finite group with a unique minimal subgroup is either cyclic of prime power order, or $Q_{4n}$ for some $n=2^i$ . We note that these groups have only regular faithful representations.
|
"generalized quaternion group" is owned by Algeboy.
|
|
(view preamble | get metadata)
Cross-references: faithful representations, power, prime, finite group, generated by, center, contradiction, contained, cyclic subgroup, structure, contain, pullback, theory, cyclic group, acyclic, index, maximal subgroups, Hamiltonian groups, finite, converse, conjugacy classes, cyclic, non-abelian group, Hamiltonian, matrices, faithful, representation, kernel, action, stabilizer, proper subgroup, degree, regular representation, faithfully, subgroup, minimal, non-Abelian, normal subgroups, division ring, cross products, quaternions, quaternion group, forces, quotient, order, words, shuffle, dihedral groups, relation, element, abelian, dihedral group properties, properties, presentation, groups
There are 2 references to this entry.
This is version 4 of generalized quaternion group, born on 2006-12-12, modified 2007-03-21.
Object id is 8620, canonical name is GeneralizedQuaternionGroup.
Accessed 5003 times total.
Classification:
| AMS MSC: | 20A99 (Group theory and generalizations :: Foundations :: Miscellaneous) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pending Errata and Addenda
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|