PlanetMath (more info)
 Math for the people, by the people. Sponsor PlanetMath
Encyclopedia | Requests | Forums | Docs | Wiki | Random | RSS  
Login
create new user
name:
pass:
forget your password?
Main Menu
Owner confidence rating: Medium Entry average rating: No information on entry rating
comprehension axiom (Definition)

The axiom of comprehension (CA) states that every formula defines a set. That is, $$\exists X\forall x(x\in X\leftrightarrow\phi(x))\text{for any formula}\phi\text{where}X\text{does not occur free in}\phi$$

The names specification and separation are sometimes used in place of comprehension, particularly for weakened forms of the axiom (see below).

In theories which make no distinction between objects and sets (such as ZF), this formulation leads to Russell's paradox, however in stratified theories this is not a problem (for example second order arithmetic includes the axiom of comprehension).

This axiom can be restricted in various ways. One possibility is to restrict it to forming subsets of sets: $$\forall Y\exists X\forall x(x\in X\leftrightarrow x\in Y\wedge\phi(x))\text{ for any formula }\phi\text{ where }X\text{ does not occur free in }\phi$$

This formulation (used in ZF set theory) is sometimes called the Aussonderungsaxiom.

Another way is to restrict $\phi$ to some family $F$ , giving the axiom F-CA. For instance the axiom $\Sigma^0_1$ -CA is: $$\exists X\forall x(x\in X\leftrightarrow\phi(x))\text{ where }\phi\text{ is }\Sigma^0_1\text{ and }X\text{ does not occur free in }\phi$$

A third form (usually called separation) uses two formulas, and guarantees only that those satisfying one are included while those satisfying the other are excluded. The unrestricted form is the same as unrestricted collection, but, for instance, $\Sigma^0_1$ separation: $$\forall x\neg(\phi(x)\wedge\psi(x))\rightarrow\exists X\forall x((\phi(x)\rightarrow x\in X)\wedge(\psi(x)\rightarrow x\notin X))$$ $$\text{ where }\phi\text{ and }\psi\text{ are }\Sigma^0_1\text{ and }X\text{ does not occur free in }\phi\text{ or }\psi$$ is weaker than $\Sigma^0_1$ -CA.




"comprehension axiom" is owned by Henry.
(view preamble | get metadata)

View style:

Other names:  CA, -CA, comprehension, comprehension axiom, axiom of comprehension, separation, separation axiom, axiom of separation, specification, specification axiom, axiom of specification, Aussonderungsaxiom
Log in to rate this entry.
(view current ratings)

Cross-references: collection, set theory, subsets, second order arithmetic, Russell's paradox, ZF, objects, theories, axiom, formula, states
There are 34 references to this entry.

This is version 7 of comprehension axiom, born on 2002-08-17, modified 2009-01-20.
Object id is 3307, canonical name is ComprehensionAxiom.
Accessed 25776 times total.

Classification:
AMS MSC03F35 (Mathematical logic and foundations :: Proof theory and constructive mathematics :: Second- and higher-order arithmetic and fragments)

Pending Errata and Addenda
None.
[ View all 3 ]
Discussion
Style: Expand: Order:
forum policy

No messages.

Interact
post | correct | update request | add derivation | add example | add (any)