Fork me on GitHub
Math for the people, by the people.

User login

PLEASE HELP

Primary tabs

PLEASE HELP

Prove that the fields real number and complex number are NOT isomorphic?


R^2 too!

That's not an isomorphism between R and C, only between R and a subset of C. All you've shown is that R is isomorphic to the real line in C.

An isomorphism needs to be bijective. You're function is into the set of complex numbers but not onto.

If they are isomorphic and f:C -> R is an isomorphism... what's the image of i ?

Hope that helps,
Alvaro

(C*,.) has an elements of order 4 (i,-i) while (R*,.) has none.

there does exist an isomorphism between the field of real numbers and complex numbers. The elements of the form (x,0) in C is isomorphic to x in R.

I just felt like opening a root level tree as I thought I could clarify some things.

alozano says :"If they are isomorphic and f:C -> R is an isomorphism... what's the image of i ?"

Suppose, there existed a isomorphism [;F:\mathbb{C}\to \mathbb{R};] and let [;f(i)=x;] for some [;x\in \mathbb{R};]. Then, [;f(1)=(f(i))^4=x^4;] which means that [;f(i)=-1;] (as [;f(1)=1;]). But [;f(i^2)=f(-1)=f(i)f(i)=1;] indicates no isomorphism.

shahab says: (C*,.) has an elements of order 4 (i,-i) while (R*,.) has none.

Note that orders of elements in a isomorphism are preserved.

Subscribe to Comments for "PLEASE HELP"